You pull into the driveway and before you've even turned the car off, something in your body shifts. Your shoulders creep up. You start running through who's going to be there, what might come up, and how you'll keep things smooth. You haven't walked through the door yet, and you're already working.
If that sounds familiar, you're not imagining it!! The holidays ask a lot of everyone, but for people-pleasers, over-givers, and anyone who grew up keeping the peace, they can feel less like a celebration and more like a performance you didn't sign up for. With the holidays coming up again….I want to bring awareness to what so many of the women I work with are going through during this time.
The holidays are supposed to be “the most wonderful time of the year” but for many people - especially those with people-pleasing, anxious, or over-extending tendencies - they can also be one of the most emotionally charged, stressful, and regressive times of the year.
Between family expectations, financial strain, travel, and the pressure to “be happy,” the holidays tend to bring old patterns and unhealed wounds right to the surface. Even if you’ve made progress in therapy, you might notice yourself slipping into old roles - the fixer, the peacemaker, the one who keeps it all together - before you even realize it.
Let’s unpack why the holidays can feel so hard for many and how to care for yourself through it!
Why We Fall Into Old Patterns Around The Holidays
For many, the holidays act like an emotional time machine. Being around family or returning to your childhood home can activate old dynamics, attachment wounds, and nervous system responses that you thought you’d outgrown.
Even if you feel secure and balanced most of the year, the holidays can bring you right back into old patterns - especially if you grew up in a family system where love was conditional, boundaries weren’t respected, or emotions weren’t safe to express.
Common triggers include:
Being asked invasive or critical questions (“When are you getting married?” “When are you having kids?” “How’s your job going?”)
Feeling responsible for other people’s emotions or comfort
Over-giving - with time, energy, or money - to keep everyone else happy
Guilt for setting boundaries, leaving early, or saying no
Comparison - feeling behind, not good enough, or disconnected from others’ highlight reels
Grief - bringing what you don’t have or lost to the surface
These reactions aren’t random - they’re your nervous system remembering. Holidays can reactivate the same dynamics that once shaped your people-pleasing, perfectionism, or anxiety.
One of the biggest reasons the holidays feel so hard is that we don't just go home. We go back into the roles we had growing up. Maybe you were the peacekeeper, the one who smoothed things over before they could turn into a fight. Maybe you were the responsible one, the easy one, or the one who always knew what Mom was feeling before she said a word. Even if you've built a whole adult life where you don't play that role anymore, it can come back the second you sit down at the table.
That's why so many people say they feel 14 again when they go home. It isn't a sign that you haven't grown or that all your work hasn't counted. Old roles pull the hardest in the exact house where you learned them. Your nervous system recognizes the people, the tension, and the patterns, and it reaches for the strategy that kept you safe back then.
It also helps to know what tends to set it off. It might be the questions: "When's the wedding?" "Are you still at that job?" "Why aren't you having kids yet?" It might be watching a parent's mood shift and feeling yourself start to manage it. It might be a sibling getting the easy pass while you do the dishes again. None of these reactions mean you're too sensitive. They mean something old got touched.
The Hidden Stress Behind the Holiday Cheer
Even positive experiences - parties, travel, or gift-giving - can overload your system. When your schedule is packed, routines are off, and expectations are high, your nervous system doesn’t get a chance to reset. For a lot of people, holiday stress doesn't start on the day itself. It starts weeks before. You find yourself planning conversations in the shower, figuring out where everyone will sit, and rehearsing how you'll respond if a certain topic comes up. That's anticipatory anxiety, and it's your nervous system trying to prepare for something it's learned to treat as a threat.
Then there's the other side of it: the crash. You get home, close the door, and your whole body just… drops. You might sleep for twelve hours, feel weepy for no clear reason, or feel strangely flat for a few days. That isn't a sign that something went wrong. It's what happens when you've been running on high alert and you finally feel safe enough to stop.
You may notice:
Heightened anxiety or irritability
Feeling more sensitive, reactive, or tearful
Fatigue, brain fog, or a sense of shutdown
Trouble relaxing, even when you’re “off”
Loneliness or sadness, even when surrounded by others
The mix of joy and stress is normal - but when you’ve spent much of your life managing others’ emotions, it can feel especially draining.
If You’re a People-Pleaser or Over-Giver: Why It Hits Harder
For people-pleasers, the holidays can quickly turn into a full-time job. You're the one hosting because no one else offered. You're spending more on gifts than you'd planned because you don't want anyone to feel left out. You're low key mediating between siblings, eating the dish you don't like so no one's feelings get hurt, and checking on everyone else's experience while barely registering your own.
From the outside it can look like generosity, and a lot of it is. But underneath, it often comes from a belief that everyone else's comfort is your responsibility, and that if anyone is unhappy, you must have done something wrong. That's a lot to carry into a season that's supposed to be about rest and connection.
For those with over-extending and fawning patterns, the holidays magnify the tension between wanting to keep the peace and needing to protect your energy.
You may find yourself:
Saying “yes” when you mean “no”
Ignoring your own needs to make others comfortable
Feeling anxious about others’ moods or reactions
Hosting, planning, and coordinating everything - then feeling resentful or exhausted
Drinking or numbing to “get through it”
It’s not because you’re unhealed - it’s because this season amplifies the very dynamics you’ve been working to unlearn.
Why Boundaries Feel So Much Harder With Family
Setting a boundary with a coworker can feel uncomfortable. Setting one with your mother on Thanksgiving can feel like the floor is falling out from under you. That's because family is where many of us first learned that saying no put connection at risk. Your body remembers that, even if your adult brain knows better and has been unlearning that!
So when you say "I'm going to head out at 7" or "I'm not going to talk about that today," you might feel a wave of guilt right after.
Here's what I want you to remember: that guilt is not proof you did something wrong. It's an old alarm going off because you did something different.
If you can let it rise, peak, and pass without rushing to fix it, explain it, or take it back, you'll notice it gets a little quieter each time.
The Pressure to Feel Joy (Even When You Don’t)
We live in a culture that romanticizes the holidays - every commercial, movie, and social media post tells us we should feel happy, connected, and full of holiday spirit.
So when you don’t - when you feel anxious, sad, irritable, or just flat - it’s easy to assume something’s wrong with you.
But there isn’t.
It’s normal to have mixed emotions during this time of year. You can be grateful for what you have and still feel grief for what’s missing. You can look forward to certain moments while also dreading others.
The expectation to feel joyful can actually deepen your distress - because when joy feels forced, you end up feeling even more disconnected. Especially for people who’ve spent years putting on a brave face, the holidays can become another performance of “I’m fine.”
Grief, Loss, and the Weight of Memory
The holidays can also illuminate what’s missing.
Maybe you’ve lost a loved one and the empty chair feels heavier this year.
Maybe you’re mourning a relationship that ended, a friendship that faded, or the version of family you wish you had.
Or maybe you’re grieving something less tangible - a sense of belonging, safety, or simplicity you never got to experience.
Even if life looks “good,” the holidays can awaken old sadness. You may feel an ache you can’t quite name - a mix of nostalgia, longing, and grief for the way things could have been.
Allowing yourself to feel that grief - instead of rushing to gratitude - is an act of compassion. It’s okay if this season feels heavy. It doesn’t mean you’re ungrateful; it means you’re human.
Tips to Stay Grounded and Boundaried This Holiday Season
1. Name What Feels Hard - and Normalize It.
You don’t need to pretend the holidays are all joy. Allow space for the both/and: both gratitude and grief, both connection and stress. Awareness reduces shame and helps you respond, not react.
2. Prepare for Triggers Ahead of Time.
Think through potential stressors: certain relatives, questions, situations, or time limits. Decide in advance how you’ll respond or what boundary you’ll hold. You can even script a few lines - “That’s not something I want to get into today, but thanks for asking” - so you’re not caught off guard.
3. Create Small, Protective Boundaries.
Boundaries don’t have to be dramatic. It could mean:
Leaving early when you’re overstimulated
Saying no to hosting or gifting beyond your budget
Taking breaks alone to reset your nervous system
Limiting alcohol if it disconnects you from yourself
Boundaries aren’t about being mean or rude, they’re about self-protection.
4. Keep a Thread of Your Routine.
Even small acts of consistency anchor your nervous system. Bring your journal, go for a walk, meditate in the morning, or listen to your calming playlist before bed. A few minutes of self-regulation goes a long way.
5. Don’t Abandon Your Own Needs.
People-pleasers often lose themselves in the swirl of others’ expectations. Pause and ask: What do I need right now? Rest? Space? Support? Permission to not be “on”? Giving yourself what you need - even if it’s uncomfortable - is a form of healing.
6. Have Emotional Support Ready.
If you can, schedule a therapy session before or after the holidays. Check in with a close friend or partner who “gets it.” Let someone know what you’re anticipating so you don’t carry it alone. Support isn’t indulgent - it’s essential.
A Final Reminder
You don’t have to perform this holiday season.
You don’t have to prove your worth through giving, hosting, or being “fine.”
You are allowed to rest.
You are allowed to have boundaries.
You are allowed to prioritize your needs this year.
The holidays may always bring some level of stress - but with awareness, boundaries, and self-compassion, they can also bring something else: clarity, healing, and a deeper connection to yourself.
Gentle Place To Start:
Take my free emotionally carrying too much quiz - to discover which nervous system pattern may be keeping you stuck.
If someone else's emotions instantly become your responsibility... if saying no fills you with guilt... if you constantly feel like it's your job to keep everyone okay...
Download my free Over-Responsibility Guide to understand this pattern - and learn how to finally put down what was never yours to carry.
About The Author
Hi! I'm Alyssa, a therapist supporting high-functioning, hyper-responsible over-givers who look like they have it together on the outside but feel anxious, chronically exhausted, and tired of being the one to support everyone else.
If you're constantly overthinking, managing other people's emotions, people-pleasing, or self-abandoning to keep the peace, my work focuses on helping you build self-trust and finally feel safe in your own needs.
My approach integrates nervous system regulation, attachment-based awareness, somatic parts work, & EMDR to help you stop over-functioning and finally feel like you can exhale.
✨ I provide online therapy, support groups, and intensives to those located in New York, New Jersey, Washington, DC, and Maryland.
Not ready for therapy yet?
✨Download my free Nervous System Workbook and subscribe to my newsletter - practical tools to understand your survival responses and begin regulating with more ease.
✨ I created The Over-Responsibility Reset - a self paced digital resource to understanding why you over-give and feel responsible for everyones emotions and break the self-abandonment, fawning, and people pleasing patterns keeping you stuck. Including a workbook, video modules, and an integration guide to help you actually shift your patterns.
📩 Email me at alyssakushnerlcsw@gmail.com
💬 Follow me on Instagram for more tips, tools, and inspiration
Disclaimer
This post is meant for educational purposes only and isn’t a substitute for diagnosis, assessment or treatment of mental conditions. If you need professional help, seek it out.